Back to the Facebook

Mar 29
2012

Social media, like Marketing, never lets you rest on your laurels. No matter how expert one may be in a medium or field, changes require constant updating, relearning, and re-honing of skills. And yet, the basics always remain the same. Yes, it’s always Back to the Future, or this week Back to the Facebook.

On Friday, March 30, 2012 Facebook is forceably changing all business sites over to its new format. The change has been a boon for the webinar industry, with every social media consultant offering tutorials on how to switch a site from the old to new format. So for all of us who believed we had mastered Facebook and were on to Pinterest, Tumblr, Wanelo, or Spotify, it was, instead, of week of back to the drawing boards on Facebook.

Back to the drawing boards must be taken literally as a key change in Facebook was the need to create a cover. Yes, all of our mothers advised us not to judge a book by its cover, but our marketing professors taught just the opposite. Packaging, aka covers, is a key marketing component, without which success is less likely in the marketplace of goods, services or ideas.  Consultants were proliferating on how to create a cover that best represents your company when Facebook rules exempt most items a classic marketer would include — namely contact info and Calls to Action.  ”The cover photo is the new landing experience,” states the SocialMouths blog.  I think experience is taking it a bit far, as it’s really a pretty picture indicative of our increasingly graphic age where people seem dazzled by image rather than substance.

Speaking of serious marketing – Facebook should, in many cases, be part of the mix, but let’s stay focused on marketing that works. In a recent sales seminar given by Mike Blinder, he unequivocally noted that for most small businesses Facebook is like a billboard in a basement. There’s tons of hype and, therefore, a strong sense that a business owner should somehow be involved in this Facebook thing, but with 25-125 followers, largely of relatives and friends, the marketing potential is limited. Blinder (pronounced Blyn-der), doesn’t wear blinders.  He calls himself a street fighter and is one of the most motivational, clear sales trainers I’ve ever heard.  As a street fighter, he believes in qualifying prospects, having a clear story to tell, doing homework on a client, and closing sales. Anything that helps him do that more successfully is marketing, but his marketing is his story of success. There’s no better kind.

There are exceptions to any rule, and Facebook marketing does have its place for some entrepreneurs– namely realtors.  Many, if not most, are women, who thrive on personal connections and local contacts.  Facebook has evolved from a teenage silo with as many moms and a growing number of grandparents Facebooking to keep up with the kids, if nothing else.  I get personal pleasure on watching my own young adult kids suddenly delving into my professional arenas on Twitter and LInked In.  If you’re talking business to business contacts, these latter two have much more to offer.

So lets Facebook the facts. Facebook was not started to be a marketing tool, but a social interaction tool. If you’re young, single and on the “meat ” market, yes it might help you market yourself.  If you’re a serious, committed entrepreneur or small business owner, it’s really the minor leagues.  The majors are playing in larger arenas, to bigger crowds (called reach), and on a consistent basis (called frequency).  They are packaging themselves as serious players, commanding well-deserved prices, and have followings that many Twitter and Facebook dabblers would crave.  Find them, and watch what they’re doing. They are your true North stars.

 

 

The new CMOS aren’t Chiefs or Marketers

Dec 12
2009

It’s well known the average CMO, meaning Chief Marketing Officer, doesn’t last even two years. No wonder. Despite all the other challenges facing a top marketing person, here’s one more: the job doesn’t exist in the new social media world!  It’s hard to hold on to a phantom job in an ever-disappearing traditional field.

The new CMO, according to social media modernist Brian Solis is a Community Management Officer.  Not responsible for getting messages out, this new position is one of engagement and relationship-building.   As Solis states in his new e-book The Art and Science of Blogger Relations: “they are on the front lines of listening and engaging in conversations across the web.”  If you don’t have a Kindle, you may not be able to read it. Solis is totally dedicated to engaging via new media replete with typos throughout the copy and all.

Unlike ivory tower Chief Marketing Officers with big corner offices in corporate complexes, the Community Management Officer is down in the trenches, trolling the web and providing valuable content in key areas.  It’s a person who tends to be ahead of the times, much like Solis who blog published his Social Media Manifesto in June 2007!

Warning: It’s not a short read — at least 11 pdf pages, in direct contrast to the average blog post.

Recommendation: Read it. It foretells the future of communication.

Since the social media world is all about making the world smaller, I was not surprised to see that Solis had co-authored a book on PR with Deidre Breckenridge, a Jersey girl who heads the PR for PFS Marketwyse, an ad agency that pitched me at the newspaper almost a decade ago.  We didn’t hire them, but they had amazing work.  They showed us an ad campaign for positioning the newspaper that I remember to this day.  We didn’t buy it , but  it was a campaign the newspaper industry as a whole through the NAA (Newspaper Association of America) should have adopted. Perhaps if they had, they’d be in better shape today.

Marketing’s Number One Lesson

Dec 06
2009

Q: What do marketing people and therapists have in common?

A: They both deal with insecurities.

Q: Is marketing a discipline that belongs in a business school, communications school, or in the school of social sciences?

A: Yes.

—————–

In his book In Search of the Obvious: The Antidote for Today’s Marketing Mess,” marketing guru Jack Trout states the obvious: “…the human mind tends to be insecure when it comes to purchasing things.” The role of marketing, he argues, is simply to make people feel more secure with a purchasing decision.  It’s also the reason, Trout notes, that a leadership is so important and should be utilized whenever possible in a marketing campaign.

In psychology, he states, it’s called the “herd mentality.” The consumer assumes that others know better and are willing to lessen their psychological risk by following others in the marketplace. If a brand is number one, it must be number one for a reason.

Ironically, many company CEOs, CMOs and Communications VPs get humble when they hold a leadership position. From watching too many Greek Tragedies, they fear corporate Hubris and being toppled from the mountaintop should their position be discovered.

Odd, isn’t it?  Marketing is about helping a company be discovered and differentiating itself in the marketplace to make a consumer’s choice fsst, easy and obvious. Nevertheless, Trout has example after example of companies who go quiet when they are, in fact, number one in their profession.

I’m facing a similar challenge with a current client, who is clearly number one in its field.  Others, with a longer history with the account, emphatically state that the client will not admit in public that they are number one in their industry. They will say the are an industry leader, have the largest network, and make many other claims that imply number one, but will not use the term. “We’re number one!”

In the recent movie Whip It, starring Drew Barrymore, the featured roller derby team consistently comes in Number Two.  They even take up the chant, “We’re number two,” after every game. Roller Derby becomes about “attitude” as is “marketing.”  I won’t tell you the end of the movie. It isn’t a formula and may not be what you expect.

Here’s an interesting fact: Roller Derby is one of three major league sports invented in the U.S.  If you count marketing as a major league sport, perhaps it’s one of four.  However, it’s no secret that there are tons of sports analogies used in business. Perhaps it’s time, we stole a few from Roller Derby.  Attitude Matters and it’s not about just going around in circles.  The goal is to come in first.

Here’s a takeaway from yet another sport – horse racing – not invented in the U.S. You can be a leader and not be number one. You can be a leader in a Win, Place or Show position. You can only be number one in the Winner’s Circle.